WARNING: this post is a rant. If you don't want to read my complaints please stop reading here. Thanks. :)
~~~~~
Now I have to admit, before this I'd never heard of the book. So I did a little research, and found that it was a really eye opening book when it came out in 1890. Basically, because there was such a economical gap between the classes, many upper class people were oblivious of the life-styles of lower class people. The author, Jacob Riis, was working to change that.
Anyway, the question asked of my class was a simple, "do you think society needs a new version of the book?" Obviously, I said yes. But for others in the class the answer was not the same. Here's my point of view: Americans seem very self-absorbed. We don't want to notice anything outside of our self-centered bubble of a life. An eye opening book, or TV show might force us do just that though. Yeah, it sounds harsh to say that our nation as a whole is self-absorbed, but it's how I feel right now. No apology there. And no, I am not saying that I am exempt from this bug.
Anyway, I checked back in with the message board a few days later, and the responses that I read from the other students really shocked me. Instead of agreeing that something needs to change, most either said that there are enough eye opening books out there, or that poverty will always be here no matter what we do.
I'm not going to lie, this made me very frustrated. I don't see how people can say that we don't need to do anything to learn about, or to help others. It just doesn't make sense to me. *Sigh*
So, I wrote the above post about a month and a half ago. I didn't post it because I wanted to go back a re-read what I wrote when I was in a less rant-ish mood. I feel the same way now as I did then. Needless to say, I'ma gonna post this. :)
Oh, and if there is any possibility that anyone is interested, here's what I posted to the class.
I think that it would be very helpful to inform Americans about the 'other half'. I don’t think that many Americans sufficiently understand what living conditions are really like in other countries, as well as in parts of America. Yes, the book by Jacob Riis probably gives a very shocking picture, but so much has changed since the early 1900s that I think that there would have to be a lot of outdated material. I do not understand how anyone could say that no good could come from an updated form of the book. It might be better if it was in the form of videos, or maybe webzines, so it could reach a broader audience, but just because there was a book published in 1890 does not mean that there is not need to be an updated version of it 2011.
Cheers,
Lauren